Welcome to Gaines Street Pies Tallahassee
At Gaines Street Pies Tallahassee, we celebrate innovation in pizza crafting amidst a vibrant atmosphere. Nestled in the heart of Tallahassee, our pizzeria redefines traditional flavors, offering a range of 10" specialty pies that embrace both the adventurous and the classic palate. From the vegan-friendly Temptation with Daiya cheese to the bold Metal Mike topped with ranch, our dishes cater to all tastes. Our friendly staff thrives on creating memorable experiences—whether enjoying a delicious calzone or pairing a pizza with a local brew from neighboring Ology Brewing Co. Join us for a slice of creativity and passion!
-
104 E 6th Ave, Tallahassee, FL 32303 Hotline: (850) 765-4120
Welcome to Gaines Street Pies Tallahassee, a delightful haven for pizza lovers and flavor adventurers alike. Located at 104 E 6th Ave, Tallahassee, FL 32303, this restaurant has quickly captured the attention of the local food scene with its innovative approach to traditional pizza.
At Gaines Street Pies, you're not just ordering a meal; you're embarking on a culinary journey. The menu offers a range of options, from classic 14" and 18" pies to unique specialty 10" creations. Each dish showcases the restaurant's commitment to quality ingredients and bold flavors.
- Bacon Bleus: A tantalizing explosion of bacon, gorgonzola, and house-roasted red peppers. It’s sure to appease any meat lover’s cravings.
- Temptation Vegan: Need a plant-based option? This pie features Daiya cheese, garlic, and a delightful combination of arugula, pineapple, and balsamic glaze.
- Margherita: Done right! This pie pairs fresh basil and smoked mozzarella with a hint of cracked black pepper, elevating the classic Margherita experience.
- Buffalo Chicken: Perfectly spicy and creamy, this pizza features buffalo sauce, chicken, and gorgonzola—an absolute must-try for those who crave a little heat.
- Garlic Knots: Don’t forget to add a side of the famous garlic knots; they’re the perfect companion to any pizza order!
Customers rave about their experiences. Robinson Rodriguez was left amazed by the "most appealing cheese pull" of a calzone that was not only visually stunning but also indulgently aromatic. Ehrin S appreciated the menu's creativity, noting how it transcends traditional pizzas to offer a variety of flavor experiences on flatbreads. With testimonials like these, it's evident that Gaines Street Pies is making a positive impact on its patrons.
The ambiance is just as inviting as the food. Located conveniently next to Ology Brewing Co., it offers a relaxed atmosphere perfect for enjoying great pies and beverages. Whether you're coming in for takeout or settling in for a meal, you’ll find a friendly and knowledgeable staff ready to enhance your dining experience.
If you find yourself in Tallahassee, don’t miss out on a visit to Gaines Street Pies. With a menu that celebrates both classic and innovative flavors, it promises a delightful culinary adventure that will keep you coming back for more. Give them a call at (850) 765-4120 to place an order or simply drop by for a slice of some of the best pie in town!
As I bit into this calzone, I was immediately hit with a sense of befuddlement how could it be this good?! It had the most appealing cheese pull visually stunning, scrumptiously tasty, indulgently aromatic, perfectly hot, and ...
This was a nice place to try. Kid was in the mood for pizza. I wasnt. Fortunately, their pizzas can get so far away from traditional pies, its basically different experiences on flat bread. This is not meant as an insult, they really thought out of the box pairing flavors and it actually works quite well.
Tried this place with my family as they recently opened this location. We had three 10 pies as well as garlic knots. Everything was absolutely delicious and fresh. My fatherinlaws pizza got caught on the chains in the oven and had a ...
Stopped by for some takeout. Parking was a little challenging but a simple pass around the block was enough to allow a spot to free up. I had ordered ahead and just needed to run in and grab my order. My order was ready and hot when they ...
Love going here for the temptation pizza. Being vegan isnt always easy when eating out and the staff is always knowledgable and makes suggestions for a great pie. Highly recommend.
Great location next to Ology Brewing Co. With good pies and a small bar in the back. The pizzas were great but a little salty. Almost gave 4 stars but the service and ambience brought it up to a 5. Tried their Margherita 4.5 stars and ...
We had a wonderful first experience! The lady I believe her name was May was phenomenal. We ordered the Caprese and a pizza. The fresh Moz was amazing! The pizza was cooked perfectly! We got a large pie 12 The White Album 12 The ...
My wife and I have been patrons of the Gaines Street location for about two years. The combination of Gaines Street Pies and Oyster City Brewing is outstanding. Im happy to report that the trend continues here in midtown. Get you a pie and ...